This is an issue arising from an international IP dispute between Konami, a well-known Japanese game production company, and Neople, a Korean game production company. Back in 2007, Konami alleged that game characters in Neople’s game titled “Shin-Ya-Gu”(New baseball) infringed Konami’s copyright in its famous baseball game “Jikkyou Yaku”(see the picture. the left image is Konami’s character and the right one is Neople’s) and filed a copyright infringement lawsuit to a Korean court.
The lower courts had overruled Konami’s claim stating a game character itself could not be protected as a copyrighted work under Korean copyright law unless such character had been commercialized independently.
This year, however, the Supreme Court of Korea dissented from the lower courts’ opinion. The Supreme Court ruled a game character can be copyrighted separated from its original work, a game. The court held that “In order to be protected under the copyright law, a work must be a creative work expressing human thoughts or emotions. Thus, in case of a character implying shape and name of person, animal and so on appearing in cartoon, television, movie, newspaper, magazine and so on, if the creative personality was shown in the visual expression as to the appearance, action of such person, animal, then such character can be a work as protected under the copyright law, apart from its original work”. Then the Supreme Court continued to held that (more…)